The swift judgment and public sentencing of Paula Deen has
truly been astonishing. It amazes me
what an incredibly harsh, vicious and mean-spirited pack of animals we are as a
society as displayed by the media which pushes the envelope every day as it
pertains to decency, common sense and bad taste. The only thing lacking in this lopsided
travesty is a burning at the stake.
I am not necessarily a fan of some of Paula Deen’s
food. I, like many of you, have watched
her show and she comes across as a pretty, plump purveyor of rich, southern
foods. She looks south, talks south and,
guess what, she is south. In short, she
has always impressed me as pretty much a ‘what you see is what you get’ type of
person. Now, of course, we all know that
TV personalities take on certain personas that may be somewhat different from
reality, but it is all acting anyway, ain’t it?
You do not get to where Paul Deen is/was without incredible hard work
and being nice to a lot of people. You
certainly don’t as a racist.
I was so curious and, frankly, intrigued by this precipitous
fall from grace that I took a few minutes to look on the internet to try to
understand how something like this could happen. Apparently, it all began with a civil lawsuit
by a former adoring white employee by the name of Lisa T. Jackson who is suing
Ms. Deen and her brother, “Bubba”, for discrimination and sexual harassment. OK, the merits of the case will stand on their
own, even though the plaintiff in question, Ms. Jackson, apparently wrote a
letter to the two just a few months previous telling them how working for them
had changed her life for the better. She
also admitted in her own deposition that she had never seen or heard Paula
discriminate or harass anyone.
I guess more of this will come out over time but it seems as
if, for some reason, she became disaffected and was suing a rich person for big
bucks. Anyway, her attorney, in a deposition
with Ms. Deen, asked if she had ever used the “N” word, to which she truthfully
replied, “Yes.” She explained the
circumstances of being a bank teller in 1987 and being robbed by one Eugene
Thomas King, Jr., a black man who nervously put a gun to her head for an extended
period demanding money be placed into a paper sack. She went on to explain she probably used the
“N” word in describing Mr. King to her husband in the privacy of their
home. She could have lied. She probably should have lied. Had she lied, the consequences she is now
enduring would never have happened. Does
anyone for a nanosecond think you can become an iconic TV personality with your
face on every grocery store magazine and be an overt racist?
Now for the big bombshell.
Ms. Deen is 66 and I am 65. She was born in 1947 and I was born in
1948. She was born in Albany, Georgia
and I was born in Miami, Florida. We
both grew up in an era, and I can remember this vividly, where bathrooms and
drinking fountains were labeled “Whites Only” and conversely, “Colored
Only”. Schools were segregated. These were the circumstances and realities in
which we both grew up and although both my parents were from Pennsylvania,
everyone around us was a long-term south Florida resident and were, for want of
a better word, “crackers”. The “N” word
was thrown about casually in front of children without any regard for what that
might mean in the future. They said it,
so we said it. Was it wrong? Of course! This is not a defense of the word, but when you grow up in this atmosphere, ignorance
will prevail and injustice will be done. That is what the civil rights movement was
(and is) about and, blessedly, most of us have moved on.
I find nigger to be just as offensive as wop, spic and heimy,
along with the entire lexicon of pejorative terms. For that matter, I don’t like honky, either,
although I am a little proud of being a first generation cracker. I don’t use these terms. In fact this is the first time I have really
had reason to think about them for as long as I can remember and only the second
time I have put it in writing (Key West Citizen January 17, 2010 story on
Martin Luther King Day). Maybe we are
making progress? At the same time, it
amazes me that Paula Deen can tell the truth about using this word after a
traumatic event over 30 years ago, in the privacy of her home, and be pillaried
for her honesty, when this word can be heard ubiquitously in the music
currently in vogue with our youth, in films and, oddly, by many African
Americans themselves in addressing one another in the common course of
conversation.
I kind of like Paula Deen but I probably won’t be eating her
recipes for fried chicken or peanut butter cheesecake, simply because it is not
the kind of food I prefer, but I have to
say that her treatment has been unduly harsh, unfair and out of proportion. I can tell you one thing. I believe those companies (Smithfield,
Walmart, Target and the Food Network) who have made money based on her hard
work, reputation and personality, but bailed on her for this momentary but
understandable lapse so many years ago, ought to be ashamed of themselves. I think, too, the racemongers who are so
quick to jump on personalities, such as in this case, had better watch out for
this may very well backfire on them in ways they don’t anticipate. Of course, this is just my opinion. I may be wrong.
Certainly, all of us should remember the wisdom of other words
spoken so long ago, “Let he who is without sin cast the first stone.”
